SINGAPORE–(BUSINESS WIRE)–Toshiba Corporation (“Toshiba”) has submitted Proposal No. 1, “Confirmation of Shareholders’ Views on Proceeding with the Examination of Strategic Reorganization,” for consideration at the Extraordinary General Meeting of Shareholders scheduled for March 24, 2022. Effissimo Capital Management Pte Ltd�s (Effissimo, we, “our”) position on this Proposal is as follows.
1. Executive Summary
2. Detailed Explanation.
The Separation, if enacted, would profoundly impact all stakeholders, and would mark a turning point both for Toshibas corporate value and for its future as a company. Because the Separation calls for a divestiture that would involve the sale of several businesses and the separation of Toshiba into two completely independent legal entities, the Separation would be irreversible meaning any error in judgment here would yield irrevocable consequences.
In order to vote in favor of the Separation, therefore, one would need to hold an unwavering conviction that the Separation would lead to a medium- to long-term increase in Toshibas corporate value. However, we are deeply concerned this is not the case given the circumstances surrounding the Separation which have been decidedly fraught, spurring a great deal of anxiety among stakeholders as well as in view of our analysis of the currently available information on the Separation and of the context that led to its deliberation. The Separation may ultimately damage Toshibas medium- to long-term corporate value.
Importantly, Toshibas Leadership Team suffers from a number of significant issues, including but not limited to the following.
First, trust has yet to be restored with shareholders and other stakeholders.1
Second, it lacks sufficient management resources.2
Third, individuals who were to be held accountable for the future impact of the Separation have resigned from their roles as executive officers of the Company.3
Fourth, the new CEO is serving on an interim basis, and has not received a vote of confidence as a director from shareholders at a general meeting of shareholders.4
Fifth, the Boards current composition is unprecedented in Japan: it does not include directors who also hold officer roles at Toshiba.5
It is evident, given the above, that Toshiba lacks the requisite Leadership Team here one that is capable of crafting a strategic plan with such irreversible and profound consequences for the Company, and which would hold accountable all parties with their associated responsibilities in order to properly execute such a plan.
What we have in front of us is a strategy that would carry irreversible and profound consequences for the Company, and which has been formulated without Toshiba having first restored the trust of all stakeholders, including shareholders. This strategic plan has yet to be vetted at a general meeting of shareholders, and the individuals who formulated the strategy have since stepped down from their executive roles, shifting accountability for its execution to newly assigned provisional executive officers, including the new Interim CEO.
As shareholders responsible for Toshibas future, we require at minimum the establishment of a Leadership Team trusted by its shareholders and other stakeholders, and for sufficient deliberations on strategy to take place under such a structure. Then, once shareholders have approved the strategy, the Board and management team that have contributed to its formulation should take ownership of it and also lead its implementation. This is the standard manner in which a corporation should be managed, and it is the way in which these highly critical matters should proceed as well.
In view of the above, we have decided to vote against Proposal 1. We believe that, in consideration of Toshibas current situation, no strategic plan should be approved that would impact the Company as irreversibly and as profoundly as would this Separation. We hope Toshiba will bring closure to the current turmoil and establish a Leadership Team that is trusted by its shareholders and other stakeholders.
1 Based on the recommendations of the Governance Enhancement Committee established in connection with the “Pressure Issue,” Toshiba states that it will continue to make efforts to restore the trust of shareholders and other stakeholders, which was undermined by the issue. (Notice Regarding Recurrence Prevention Measures Based on Suggestions in Investigation Report of Governance Enhancement Committee dated Dec. 16, 2021)
2 Toshiba had initially planned to elect 13 directors at last years annual general meeting of shareholders, but the number of directors has been reduced to 8 as a result of the withdrawal or rejection of some director nominees for election, as well as a director resignation. Consequently, the number of directors remains below that considered appropriate by Toshibas own Corporate Governance Guidelines.
3 The CEO and Corporate Senior Executive Vice President were both representative executive officers and directors playing a central role in formulating the proposed Separation, and should be held responsible for the Separations future impact on Toshiba, yet both have abruptly resigned as executive officers effective March 1, 2022.
4 The new CEO and COO are still undergoing a performance review by the Board and are said to be interim a term articulated to mean they will remain provisional until they are confirmed to be performing well enough to be suitable for the role of representative executive officers.
5 As the two representative executive officers have resigned from their executive roles, the Boards current composition does not include directors who also hold officer roles, meaning there is no company management representation on the board. This will remain the case for roughly four months from the current date, until the annual general meeting.
Contacts
[ Media Contacts ]
VOX Global Japan K.K.
Kei Kuhara / Shihoko Fujisawa / Ryoji Tanabe
TEL: +81-3-6204-4358 / +81-3-6204-4347 / +81-3-6204-4337
BEIJING, CHINA - Media OutReach Newswire - 22 November 2024 - The 2024 Beijing Changping…
Tickets Now Available via Urbtix HONG KONG SAR - Media OutReach Newswire - 22 November…
iShopChangi is throwing a year-end bash like no other! From now till December, get ready…
HONG KONG SAR - Media OutReach Newswire - 22 November 2024 - As a leading…
HONG KONG SAR - Media OutReach Newswire - 22 November 2024 - As a leading…
HONG KONG SAR - Media OutReach Newswire - 22 November 2024 - Minsuzenraku, Taiwan's highly…